The “First Salute” in historical perspective Myth and Imperial Realities in Sint Eustatius
.jpg)
It is commonly believed that Sint Eustatius ("Statia") was the first territory to formally acknowledge the newly independent United States because of the famous cannon salute fired from Fort Oranje on November 16, 1776, to the Continental Navy brig Andrew Doria. This act alone occupies a cherished place in American and Caribbean lore.
But as we mark the 250th anniversary of this event with the presence of King Willem-Alexander, a critical historical look would reveal that this was far less an official diplomatic recognition by a sovereign state and much more a pragmatic, commercially driven gesture made within a deeply unequal Atlantic world.
But before we dig deeper into that, it is worth noting another very important event that took place on Statia on Friday, the 13th of November, 2026. No superstition is attached to this date as the remains of the 69 African ancestors excavated from the Golden Rock Burial Ground in 2021 were finally reburied in a solemn ceremony officiated by Nkosazana Illis.
King Willem-Alexander, who had officially “apologized” for the role of the Dutch kingdom in the evil system of TransAtlantic chattel Slavery, could have timed his presence on Statia to enable him attend the reburial of the 69 ancestors who were victims of Dutch enslavement. But he did not. In fact, how many of the official Dutch representatives on St. Eustatius, attended that ceremony if even to pay their respects?
Yet, here we are, glorifying a cannon salute which on closer historical scrutiny begs the question:
Was the Cannon Salute from a Sovereign State? This is a pertinent and logical question to ask. The answer is, of course, a big NO.
Sint Eustatius was not a sovereign state in 1776 and still is not up to this day. Neither did Governor Johannes de Graaff possess the authority to grant formal legal recognition (de jure recognition) to a foreign power on behalf of the Dutch Republic.
Under international law of the 18th century, returning a gun salute — known as a custom of maritime protocol —acknowledged the arrival of a vessel and signaled basic maritime respect. While the Americans enthusiastically interpreted the returned fire (11 guns answering the Andrew Doria's 13) as an acknowledgment of their new flag and independence, De Graaff’s actions were driven by protocol and commercial diplomacy rather than formal foreign policy.
Furthermore, the Staats-General in The Hague had explicitly declared neutrality in the conflict between Great Britain and its North American colonies. When Great Britain learned of the salute, they protested fiercely, forcing the Dutch government to reprimand Governor De Graaff and recall him to answer for his breach of diplomatic protocol.
Moreover, we must not forget who was in absolute control of Sint Eustatius when the salute happened. In 1776, Sint Eustatius was a colony administered by the Dutch West India Company (WIC) on behalf of the Dutch Republic (the Republic of the Seven United Netherlands).
Due to its duty-free status and neutral stance, the tiny 8-square-mile island had earned the moniker "The Golden Rock". It functioned as one of the busiest global trade hubs in the Atlantic world. Merchants from Britain, France, Spain, and North America traded alongside Dutch merchants in Statia’s harbor (Oranjestad), moving sugar, rum, textiles, gunpowder, arms, provisions, and enslaved Africans, making it a vital supply pipeline for the Continental Army.
In fact, the wealth that earned Statia its "Golden Rock" title was fundamentally built upon and sustained by the Trans-Atlantic chattel Slavery for which Sint Eustatius was a primary transshipment hub.
The island served as a major central marketplace where enslaved African men, women, and children were forcibly trafficked, auctioned, and transshipped to sugar and coffee plantations across the Greater and Lesser Antilles and to the United States.
On the island itself, enslaved Africans provided the manual labor necessary to build and maintain the massive warehouse complexes lining Lower Town, construct the fortifications, load and unload merchant vessels in the bay, and work on local agricultural estates, all for no pay.
The economic vibrancy that allowed Statia to salute an incoming ship carrying the ideals of American "liberty" relied directly on an economic system that denied human rights and even humanity to thousands of enslaved Africans. It is one of those weird contradictions of history that descendants of those enslaved Africans would today be celebrating that first salute.
Today, Sint Eustatius is a special municipality (officially an openbaar lichaam or public entity) of the Netherlands.
In 2010, following the dissolution of the Netherlands Antilles, Statia, which was the only island territory to vote in a referendum to remain part of the Netherlands Antilles, was co-opted directly into the Netherlands proper without any further plebiscite.
Therefore, a critical analysis of the 1776 salute transforms a simple tale of ideological solidarity into a complex narrative about imperial geopolitics, global trade, and selective memory.
All the evidence shows that the salute was not primarily an act of revolutionary brotherhood, but an expression of free trade. Statia welcomed American ships because American trade was enormously profitable for Dutch and local merchants. It was therefore simply a case of capitalism over ideology.
In my humble view, commemorating the "First Salute" as a milestone for human liberty overlooks the structural hypocrisy of the era. The salute linked two societies — the fledgling U.S. and colonial Sint Eustatius — that were both profiting from and enforcing the evil system of chattel Slavery while proclaiming their own individual freedom.
Besides, we often ignore that the imperial fallout for Sint Eustatius was uncompromising. That “First Salute” carried heavy consequences.
In 1781, Great Britain declared war on the Dutch Republic (the Fourth Anglo-Dutch War), citing Statia's illicit trade with the American rebels as a reason. British Admiral George Rodney captured and plundered the island, dealing a blow to its economy from which it never fully recovered.
Commemorating the salute should, therefore, not merely be about celebrating a footnote in U.S. diplomatic history, rather, it should offer a golden opportunity to reflect on how small, colonized Caribbean islands were positioned at the center of global power struggles, economic networks, and human exploitation that shaped the modern Atlantic world.
How can we reconcile the commemoration of the “First Salute” with the reburial on Friday of the remains of the 69 enslaved ancestors? How do their descendants feel about the restoration and memorialization of their humanity against the backdrop of the commemoration of a cannon salute which denied them not only their freedom but also their dignity?

