Kingdom relations under pressure as instability hits all four countries

THE HAGUE--Cooperation within the Kingdom is under strain amid political instability in all four countries, according to the Council of State, which on Tuesday used its annual report to warn that inconsistent governance and weak continuity in Kingdom relations are undermining progress on shared priorities.

Citing frequent changes in leadership, the Council noted that Dutch ministers responsible for Kingdom relations have changed across three different cabinets in the past four years, while parliamentary elections were also held in three of the four Kingdom countries last year, contributing to uncertainty and concern across the Kingdom.

The Council said the issue formed the core of the chapter devoted to Kingdom affairs in its annual report, released Tuesday. It pointed to the need for more stable, consistent and productive relations within the Kingdom, especially as the countries continue to face common challenges.

According to the report, the 70th anniversary of the Charter for the Kingdom was commemorated in December 2024, following an advisory opinion issued in October 2024 calling for better and more productive Kingdom relations based on cooperation and mutual understanding. While that advice was reportedly received positively across the Kingdom, the Council noted that a joint position expected to be reflected in a follow-up report by the Kingdom Council of Ministers was omitted in 2025.

The Council said it intends to remain closely engaged in the public sector and private sector in the Caribbean parts of the Kingdom, as well as in European Netherlands, to strengthen connections and contribute to improving ties within the Kingdom. It noted that in October 2025 it welcomed a new State Councilor of the Kingdom for St. Maarten in the person of Randolph Nuggs.

The report also referenced the Kingdom Day 2025 celebration held on December 15 at The Hague University of Applied Sciences in collaboration with the Ministry of the Interior and Kingdom Relations and the Council of State. During that event, Vice-President Thom de Graaf directly addressed concerns about Kingdom relations.

De Graaf said the Kingdom often focuses too much on what is going wrong, particularly from a regional Caribbean perspective, while not doing enough to improve cooperation in practical ways. He argued that the Kingdom can and should function better, especially in tackling shared issues such as poverty, education, security and economic autonomy.

He further stressed that countries and islands across the Kingdom should not waste time on competence battles or rigid divisions over responsibility, but should instead find ways to collaborate more forcefully, share knowledge and work together across borders wherever possible.

The Council’s comments come against a backdrop of longstanding frustrations in the Caribbean parts of the Kingdom about how cooperation functions in practice, particularly when governments change and policy direction shifts. The report suggests that without stronger continuity and a more deliberate commitment to mutual understanding, the Kingdom risks repeating cycles of stalled cooperation at a time when coordinated action is needed most.

By placing the issue so prominently in its annual report, the Council is also signaling that Kingdom relations can no longer be treated as a ceremonial or secondary matter. Instead, it is framing cooperation, trust and policy consistency as central to the functioning of the Kingdom itself, especially as all four countries face pressure to deliver on social, economic and governance challenges that increasingly demand joint effort rather than fragmented responses.

‍