Dutch Parliament approves tax plan despite VVD opposition, coalition crisis deepens

THE HAGUE--The Dutch House of Representatives approved the government's amended 2027 Tax Plan on Thursday evening, November 12, despite opposition from one of the three governing coalition parties, creating further uncertainty over the future of Prime Minister Rob Jetten's administration.

The legislation passed the Tweede Kamer with 76 of the 150 members voting in favor, securing the narrowest possible majority. The outcome followed hours of debate over a controversial agreement between coalition parties D66 and CDA and opposition parties PRO and Volt to increase taxation on income from savings and investments while reducing taxes on employment income.

The third coalition partner, VVD, voted against the legislation after warning that the proposed changes violated the coalition agreement. Its opposition did not prevent the legislation from passing, but the disagreement has raised questions about whether the three-party minority government can continue functioning together.

Prime Minister Jetten is now expected to meet with Deputy Prime Ministers Dilan Yeşilgöz of the VVD and Bart van den Brink of the CDA on Friday morning in an attempt to resolve the dispute and determine how the coalition can move forward.

The disagreement began when D66 and CDA negotiated a tax compromise with PRO and Volt without securing the VVD's support. The agreement was intended to obtain the parliamentary backing needed to advance the government's tax legislation, but it also created a confrontation among the governing parties.

The minority coalition holds only 66 seats in the 150-member House of Representatives and depends on opposition parties to pass legislation.

Tax burden to shift toward investment income

At the center of the disagreement is a proposal to transfer approximately €1 billion in taxation away from employment income and toward higher investment returns and other wealth-related income.

The approved changes include a new 38.5 percent tax rate on returns exceeding €60,000 under the Netherlands' box 3 taxation system, which covers savings and investments. The basic rate on returns below that threshold would be reduced from 36 percent to 35.5 percent.

Revenue generated by the changes would help finance reductions in income taxes, particularly for lower- and middle-income earners.

The measures received support from D66, CDA, PRO, Volt, ChristenUnie, DENK, the Party for the Animals (PvdD) and 50PLUS.

The VVD opposed the revised package, maintaining that higher taxes on investment income could negatively affect the Dutch economy and investment environment.

Before the vote, VVD parliamentary leader Ruben Brekelmans had warned that his party would reject the government's tax legislation if the disputed amendment was adopted.

The party followed through on that position, voting against legislation introduced by a government in which it continues to serve.

Coalition leaders face critical discussions

The parliamentary outcome leaves Prime Minister Jetten attempting to preserve a coalition that has been in office for less than nine months.

VVD leader Yeşilgöz previously expressed dissatisfaction with the negotiations conducted by D66 and CDA, calling for a fundamental reassessment of cooperation within the government.

Jetten has indicated that he intends to work toward restoring relations between the coalition partners rather than allowing the disagreement to bring down the administration.

The Prime Minister has defended the value of continued cooperation among D66, VVD and CDA, pointing to major policy challenges, including housing development and nitrogen emissions, that require government action.

However, the VVD has not publicly committed to continuing under the existing arrangements without further discussions.

Although the tax legislation secured a parliamentary majority, the vote demonstrated that the government cannot automatically rely on support from all three coalition parties for its legislative agenda.

The disagreement also raises broader questions about how the minority administration will negotiate future legislation when its coalition partners disagree on fundamental economic policies.

Senate approval still required

Despite Thursday's approval in the Tweede Kamer, the 2027 Tax Plan must still be considered by the Eerste Kamer, the Dutch Senate.

The parties supporting the legislation in the lower house do not collectively hold enough seats to guarantee its passage in the Senate. Additional support will therefore be necessary before the legislation can take effect.

A separate proposal concerning taxation of actual investment returns under box 3 received broader support in the Tweede Kamer, including from JA21, SGP and BBB. That development could improve its prospects in the Senate, although approval is not assured.

The Dutch government is seeking to complete the legislative process before the beginning of 2027.

For now, the immediate political focus shifts to Friday's discussions among the coalition leadership.

The outcome will help determine whether the Jetten administration can continue governing under its existing coalition agreement, whether new arrangements will be necessary, or whether the disagreement develops into a broader government crisis.

Thursday's vote has secured passage of the amended tax plan through the lower house, but it has left the political future of the government that introduced it unresolved.

‍